LU Notes Admin

LuNotes – your trusted for Lucknow University Semester exam notes, crafted with love. ❤️

Meaning of the Amendment of the Constitution

• Constitutional Amendment refers to modifying or updating any provision of the Constitution through a defined process.

• This ensures the Constitution remains adaptable while maintaining its core values.

Provisions of Amendment of the Indian Constitution

• Article 368 in Part XX of the Constitution defines the amendment process.

• The Constitution can be changed through:

  • Adding, changing, or removing provisions.

  • Keeping the Constitution responsive to evolving needs.

Procedure for Amendment of the Indian Constitution

1. Introduction of Amendment Bill:

   • Introduced in either house of Parliament (not State Legislatures).

   • Can be proposed by a minister or private member.

   • No need for President’s permission to introduce.

2. Passing the Bill:

   • Requires a Special Majority in both houses:

     • 50% of total membership + 2/3rd majority of members present and voting.

3. Ratification by States (if federal provisions are involved):

   • If changes affect federal structure, half of the State Legislatures must ratify with a simple majority.

4. President’s Assent:

   • The President must give assent to the bill.

   • Once approved, the bill becomes a Constitutional Amendment Act.

Types of Constitutional Amendments

1. By Simple Majority of Parliament:

   • 50% of members present and voting can amend provisions such as:

     • Establishment of new states.

     • Formation or alteration of boundaries.

2. By Special Majority of Parliament:

   • Most provisions amended by this method, including:

     • Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles.

     • Provisions that do not fall under simple majority or state consent.

3. By Special Majority of Parliament and State Consent:

   • Required for amendments impacting federal structure, such as:

     • President’s election or changes in the executive powers of the Union and States.

Basic Structure Doctrine

• Basic Structure refers to the core principles that cannot be altered or destroyed.

• Kesavananda Bharati Case (1973): The Supreme Court ruled that even Parliament cannot amend the Constitution in a way that violates its basic structure.

• Ensures that the essential spirit of the Constitution remains intact.

Significance of Constitutional Amendments

1. Adaptability in Governance:

   • Enables the Constitution to evolve with changing political, social, and economic needs.

2. New Rights and Reforms:

   • Facilitates recognition and protection of new rights (e.g., Right to Privacy).

   • Supports social reforms by addressing outdated practices.

3. Addressing Emerging Issues:

   • Helps address new challenges like vigilantism or emerging societal demands.

Criticism of the Amendment Procedure

• Lack of Special Amendment Body:

  • The absence of a Constitutional Convention or special body to handle amendments.

  • Parliament alone holds the power to initiate amendments.

• State Consent Limitation:

  • States only have limited power in the amendment process (only in cases affecting the federal structure).

• No Joint Sitting:

  • No provision for a joint sitting of both Houses in case of disagreement, leading to possible deadlock.

LuNotes – your trusted for Lucknow University Semester exam notes, crafted with love. ❤️

Emergency Provisions in India

Overview:
In India, a state of emergency can be declared by the President during a crisis. This allows the President to override certain constitutional provisions, including Fundamental Rights, to ensure the country’s security and stability. The provisions are found in Part XVIII (Articles 352-360) of the Indian Constitution.

Types of Emergency

1. National Emergency (Article 352)
   
   This can be declared in cases of:

   • War

   • External aggression

   • Armed rebellion (formerly internal disturbance)

   The emergency can be declared even before the threat actually occurs.

   Approval and Duration:

   • The proclamation must be approved by both Houses of Parliament within one month.

   • It lasts for 6 months and can be extended with parliamentary approval every 6 months.

   Effects:

   • Centre-State Relations: The Centre gains control over state matters, with the power to issue executive orders and make laws on state subjects.

   • Parliamentary Power: Parliament can legislate on subjects in the State List.

   • Tenure of Assemblies: The tenure of the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies can be extended.

   • Fundamental Rights:

     • Article 19: Suspension of certain rights like freedom of speech, movement, etc.

     • Article 359: The President can suspend the enforcement of other Fundamental Rights, except Articles 20 and 21 (protection against arrest and conviction).

   Historical Examples:

   • 1962: Declared during the China-India war.

   • 1971: During the India-Pakistan war.

   • 1975: Proclaimed due to internal disturbances (Emergency imposed by Indira Gandhi).

2. President’s Rule (Article 356)
   
   If the government of a state fails to function according to the Constitution, the President can assume direct control of the state government. This is commonly known as President’s Rule.

   Grounds for Declaration:

   • Failure of the state government to follow constitutional provisions.

   • If the state government does not comply with directives from the Centre (Article 365).

   Approval and Duration:

   • Must be approved by both Houses of Parliament within two months.

   • Can be extended indefinitely by a special majority in Parliament every 6 months.

   Consequences:

   • The President takes over the state executive functions.

   • The state legislature’s powers may be transferred to Parliament.

   • The President may issue ordinances for the state.

   Judicial Review:
   
   The 44th Amendment Act (1978) allowed judicial review of the President’s satisfaction for declaring President’s Rule, which was previously non-reviewable.

3. Financial Emergency (Article 360)
   
   This can be declared if the financial stability or credit of India or any part of its territory is threatened.

   Approval and Duration:

   • Must be approved by both Houses of Parliament within two months.

   • Once approved, it continues until revoked.

   Effects:

   • The Union gains authority over state finances.

   • The President can reduce the salaries of state officials, including judges.

   • Financial bills in states are reserved for the President’s consideration.

Criticism of Emergency Provisions

While the emergency provisions are meant to protect the country during crises, they have faced criticism:

• Centralization of Power: Critics argue that they give excessive power to the Union government, weakening the federal structure.

• Dictatorship Risk: There is a fear that the President can become authoritarian.

• Impact on Fundamental Rights: These provisions allow the suspension of Fundamental Rights, undermining democracy.